• Register
  • TOS
  • Privacy
  • @NeoGAF
  • Like

Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
(10-10-2017, 06:01 AM)
Grizzlyjin's Avatar
- Right off the bat, I like some of the choices they made here. Even tiny touches like the supergirl logo in the intro being darker. Also the dialogue was snappier, characters didn't sit and wait for reaction shots, they just went for it. They also didn't overplay the Dark Supergirl stuff. She's just sorta depressed and straight to business, but eventually found her way back to her friends.
- WHOA, Lena's accent was slipping in that boardroom scene. Been a long summer, eh. lol
- I like seeing Adrian Pasdar in things. He's fun on Agents of SHIELD
- Very well directed episode, I loved that shot of Kara, Wynn, J'onn, and Alex talking at the DEO as the camera panned around them.
- This Morgan Edge timing is perfect for me. I knew nothing about him before, but I was going through Jack Kirby's 4th World comics this summer and Edge is introduced in the Jimmy Olsen series there. Except in that he's buying the Daily Planet and just fucks with Clark Kent constantly. lol
- James was way outta line using the watch to have a chat. That's dangerous.
- At least the Supergirl statue is better than that janky ass one Black Canary got lol

I was so ready to drop this show, but the premiere was promising. Only quibble would be it still feels like a sports anime during the 3rd act fights. Kara does awesome stuff, all the DEO characters stand around narrating and explaining.
dead souls
(10-10-2017, 07:27 AM)
Solid premiere.

Totally embarrassing to admit, but I almost teared up when Alex was asking Hank to walk her down the aisle.
morningbus
Serious Sam is a wicked gahbidge series for chowdaheads.
(10-10-2017, 07:37 AM)
morningbus's Avatar

Originally Posted by Grizzlyjin

- James was way outta line using the watch to have a chat. That's dangerous.

Sorry, but Flash-GAF told me Patty Spivot did nothing wrong.

Originally Posted by dead souls

Solid premiere.

Totally embarrassing to admit, but I almost teared up when Alex was asking Hank to walk her down the aisle.

I have to hand it to the actors because I don't really know why the scene was actually so effective.
ZeroX03
Member
(10-10-2017, 07:48 AM)
ZeroX03's Avatar

Originally Posted by morningbus

Sorry, but Flash-GAF told me Patty Spivot did nothing wrong.

Flash wasn’t out doing superheroics at the time.
Septimus Prime
Member
(10-10-2017, 09:08 AM)
Septimus Prime's Avatar
It really sucks to watch J'onn just chillin' when he could totally handle things. Like, okay, Supergirl can't breathe underwater. He can. Shapeshift into a fish or Aquaman or something else with gills. But why do that instead of nothing, right?
caliph95
Member
(10-10-2017, 10:39 AM)
caliph95's Avatar

Originally Posted by Septimus Prime

It really sucks to watch J'onn just chillin' when he could totally handle things. Like, okay, Supergirl can't breathe underwater. He can. Shapeshift into a fish or Aquaman or something else with gills. But why do that instead of nothing, right?

Because J'onn isn't allowed to be much use
Magwik
Banned
(10-10-2017, 11:02 AM)
Anytime J'obber is out in the field something usually goes horribly wrong. Dude should stay inside as much as possible.
caliph95
Member
(10-10-2017, 11:03 AM)
caliph95's Avatar
Remember when J'onn is supposed to be more powerful than SuperMan and that Clark was afraid of him
Sir Doom
Member
(10-10-2017, 01:41 PM)
Sir Doom's Avatar
Really used super hearing to listen to hurt beat. Oh all things to focus. She must have data based heart beats.

Meh Lana part of Kat co. Trying to condense all this character as part of Kara's bubble.

Who is Mom of Steel?
ZeroX03
Member
(10-10-2017, 03:08 PM)
ZeroX03's Avatar
Season 2 soundtrack live on Spotify (and more)!

Supergirl S2

Arrow S5
The Flash S3
Legends S2
Toa TAK
Banned
(10-10-2017, 03:34 PM)

Originally Posted by dead souls

Solid premiere.

Totally embarrassing to admit, but I almost teared up when Alex was asking Hank to walk her down the aisle.

That was the best part of the episode for me.

Originally Posted by ZeroX03

Season 2 soundtrack live on Spotify (and more)!

Supergirl S2

Arrow S5
The Flash S3
Legends S2

These soundtracks are great. Neely and his team really stepped it up last year.
Munter
Member
(10-10-2017, 09:32 PM)
Munter's Avatar

Originally Posted by Sir Doom

Who is Mom of Steel?

Erica Durance, who of course played Lois Lane in Smallville
Cafeman
Member
(10-10-2017, 09:47 PM)
Cafeman's Avatar
What? Why did they switch actresses on Kara's mother?
caliph95
Member
(10-10-2017, 09:49 PM)
caliph95's Avatar
Yeah I noticed Lena accent
That bothered me because I was keep thinking "I'm sure she was American"
Kevinroc
Member
(10-10-2017, 09:51 PM)
Kevinroc's Avatar

Originally Posted by Cafeman

What? Why did they switch actresses on Kara's mother?

Laura Benanti (who had played Kara's mother previously) was committed to other projects, so the Supergirl team decided to recast.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/liv...enanti-1019448

It was all right there when they announced they had cast Erica Durance.
Pachimari
Member
(10-10-2017, 10:36 PM)
So Edge is Talbot? Holy shit I knew I had seen him somewhere else!

It was an okay episode. I'm still sad there ain't much time spent on CatCo and her work there, and the time we spent with the DEO but that's what this show I about unfortunately. Good to see she's gonna embrace Kara again at the end of the episode cause I really need a way more optimistic Supergirl who loves what's she's doing. I'm probably not gonna get that either.

The ending was interesting. I just hope we won't get another invasion by a foreign alien species like the Daxamites again. Oh yeah I liked the shot of all the friends hanging out by the table.

The underwater scene looked really bad, like it wasn't even water. Her lifting up the submarine looked good though. I liked Cat's appearances on the TV's and wouldn't mind if that's how we get to see her this season.
FoneBone
Member
(10-11-2017, 03:36 AM)
FoneBone's Avatar

Originally Posted by Freddy=Legend

Katie McGrath's accent has been slipping out a little this episode. Maybe my ears just playing tricks on me.

This episode is admittedly the worst I've seen it, but when hasn't it been slipping?
Sir Doom
Member
(10-11-2017, 05:39 AM)
Sir Doom's Avatar

Originally Posted by Munter

Erica Durance, who of course played Lois Lane in Smallville

Damn didn't recognized her
rockman zx
Member
(10-11-2017, 06:34 AM)
rockman zx's Avatar
Alex is killing this show for me, I can't stand her drama. I hope she gets married soon and find happiness, lol
Toa TAK
Banned
(10-11-2017, 06:35 AM)

Originally Posted by rockman zx

Alex is killing this show for me, I can't stand her drama. I hope she gets married soon and find happiness, lol

LOL
WrenchNinja
Member
(10-11-2017, 06:47 AM)
Did they recast Alura?
Wingfan19
Member
(10-11-2017, 08:15 AM)
Wingfan19's Avatar

Originally Posted by WrenchNinja

Did they recast Alura?

Check like 7 posts up... It's Erica Durance now.
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
(10-11-2017, 10:59 AM)
Grizzlyjin's Avatar

Originally Posted by Pachimari

I liked Cat's appearances on the TV's and wouldn't mind if that's how we get to see her this season.

I was thinking the same thing. Be cool if they just have her film a bunch of goofy Press Secretary bits and then sprinkle them around the season.
ZeroX03
Member
(10-11-2017, 11:15 AM)
ZeroX03's Avatar
The Press Secretary stuff is easy to shoot (can do it in LA), is easily inserted and can be timely commentary. I like it.
caliph95
Member
(10-11-2017, 11:18 AM)
caliph95's Avatar
"Of course the president doesn't spend her time, she's not some callous lazy asshole"

"Of course she doesn't follow fox news and breitbart, she has standards you know"
IbukiLordSA
Member
(10-11-2017, 11:57 AM)
IbukiLordSA's Avatar
Submarine scene was great, rarely see feats like that on TV shows but the best surprise was Nola being in the show now, that's awesome, and apparently she will be playing Reign, sweet.
Cafeman
Member
(10-12-2017, 02:02 AM)
Cafeman's Avatar

Originally Posted by Kevinroc

Laura Benanti (who had played Kara's mother previously) was committed to other projects, so the Supergirl team decided to recast.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/liv...enanti-1019448

It was all right there when they announced they had cast Erica Durance.

Okay , got it. By the way, has everyone heard Laura Benanti sing? Incredible singer. Watch her on YT at kennedy center for Tom Hanks.
Platy
Member
(10-12-2017, 02:07 AM)
Platy's Avatar
Loved the press secretary parts
loved the man of steel references and jabs
loved the action
loved the low amount of monel
love the cute moment of alex and johnz

awesome first episode
Ricker
Member
(10-12-2017, 02:11 PM)
Ricker's Avatar
Erica Durance(Lois Lane in Smallville),Supergirl billboard in the season 3 premiere of Lucifer and Tom Welling in Lucifer(Superman in Smallville)...weird episode coming...? lol ;)

Great season opener,I hope it keeps up,some episodes last year where pretty average compared to season 1.
Joni
Member
(10-12-2017, 10:43 PM)
Joni's Avatar
Love Asshole Kara. It is nice the show plays into this, having this actually impact the characters and have them be right for it. Other Arrowverse shows have done a bit too much 'cranky hero was right' stories.
Ragnarsson
Member
(10-13-2017, 10:28 PM)
Ragnarsson's Avatar
That was a pretty good premiere. Some thoughts:

Edge feels like a worthy replacement for Maxwell Lord, which is good (also, Adrian Pasdar is a very inspired choice for this role); I was surprised by the directing in this episode, it felt better than usual for a CW show; the acting was also surprisingly on point (probably also related to the directing); please, keep attacking Trump, I need me some catharsis; Katie McGrath might as well stop trying to come up with an American accent, her original accent is great and this weird mixture is just distracting; I really liked the way they addressed Mon-El's disappearance from Kara's point of view, it felt believable, good stuff; they better not mess with Alex and Maggie; oh, and James still exists, so that's... something!
Joni
Member
(10-13-2017, 10:47 PM)
Joni's Avatar

Originally Posted by Ragnarsson

Oh, and James still exists, so that's... something!

He must be thrilled that his ex-girlfriend who he hounded is the bestie of his new boss.
Shaanyboi
Banned
(10-13-2017, 10:51 PM)
Solid episode. Some of the show's better-directed dramatic moments (though the crowd looking stupidly calm during the submarine rising kinda took me out of it).

Some genuinely good jokes here and there, with Wynn on the comm and Alex's "biggest gayest wedding."

Adrian Pasdar is a solid addition.


Good stuff.
StarCreator
Member
(10-13-2017, 10:53 PM)
StarCreator's Avatar
Wait, if Pasdar is in this then...

:(
Ragnarsson
Member
(10-14-2017, 12:19 AM)
Ragnarsson's Avatar

Originally Posted by Joni

He must be thrilled that his ex-girlfriend who he hounded is the bestie of his new boss.

Haha! I honestly couldn't care less about James, though. They keep trying to make him happen, but he's not an interesting character in this iteration, in both the concept and execution departments. First he was a reporter living under Clark's shadow, then he was tangled in that Lane family storyline and at the same time he was Kara's love interest (never before seen chemistry between those two...), then he became the new Cat (which... no, just... no), also a new vigilante (which... why? And how? And why, again?), now he's trying to act like he juggles his vigilante persona and his professional life like a pro (which... I mean, I had to endure season 2, sorry James, can't buy your act). Might as well write him off.
jph139
Member
(10-14-2017, 12:21 AM)
jph139's Avatar
Pasdar as Morgan Edge is the tops, always excited to see more of him. Real highlight of the episode for me.

But overall... nah. Did not convince me to keep tuning in. Sorry Supergirl - when you're on Netflix, if I hear good things.
caliph95
Member
(10-14-2017, 03:01 AM)
caliph95's Avatar

Originally Posted by Ragnarsson

Haha! I honestly couldn't care less about James, though. They keep trying to make him happen, but he's not an interesting character in this iteration, in both the concept and execution departments. First he was a reporter living under Clark's shadow, then he was tangled in that Lane family storyline and at the same time he was Kara's love interest (never before seen chemistry between those two...), then he became the new Cat (which... no, just... no), also a new vigilante (which... why? And how? And why, again?), now he's trying to act like he juggles his vigilante persona and his professional life like a pro (which... I mean, I had to endure season 2, sorry James, can't buy your act). Might as well write him off.

You know if James got poochied I wouldn't mindames got poochied I wouldn't mind
Joni
Member
(10-14-2017, 08:55 AM)
Joni's Avatar

Originally Posted by Ragnarsson

Haha! I honestly couldn't care less about James, though. They keep trying to make him happen, but he's not an interesting character in this iteration, in both the concept and execution departments. First he was a reporter living under Clark's shadow, then he was tangled in that Lane family storyline and at the same time he was Kara's love interest (never before seen chemistry between those two...), then he became the new Cat (which... no, just... no), also a new vigilante (which... why? And how? And why, again?), now he's trying to act like he juggles his vigilante persona and his professional life like a pro (which... I mean, I had to endure season 2, sorry James, can't buy your act). Might as well write him off.

He can make a big sacrifice to bring some real repercussions to the show.
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
(10-14-2017, 09:48 AM)
Freshmaker's Avatar

Originally Posted by Pachimari

Last season was so incredibly bad, I've actually lost faith this team can turn this around. I would like James to drop his Guardian persona, maybe get some more time in at the newspaper, and just drop the whole DEO. This show probably won't ever really be what I wanted it to be, but I'll give it a few more episodes and see how it goes this season.

It should drop one or the other. Dunno why they even bother with jobs at Catco unless rent's just too damn high or something in that city.
Joni
Member
(10-14-2017, 10:39 AM)
Joni's Avatar

Originally Posted by Freshmaker

It should drop one or the other. Dunno why they even bother with jobs at Catco unless rent's just too damn high or something in that city.

I can imagine Jon claiming he shouldn't pay Kara because she is doing volunteer work.
Volimar
Member
(10-14-2017, 11:42 AM)
Volimar's Avatar
Lena's accent slipped a bit, huh. When she said Catco when talking to Adrian Pasdar for one.


Did they recast Kara's mom?

Edit: Reading up, I see that they did.
Joni
Member
(10-14-2017, 12:36 PM)
Joni's Avatar

Originally Posted by Volimar

Lena's accent slipped a bit, huh. When she said Catco when talking to Adrian Pasdar for one.

She sounds hotter with her original accent instead of her fake American one.
LotusHD
Banned
(10-15-2017, 05:37 AM)
Finally watched the episode. I gotta say, Kara in this premiere probably the best depiction of the whole "mopey superhero" trope that I've seen regarding the CW superhero shows. When Barry, Oliver or the supporting cast acts all depressed, I inevitably end up rolling my eyes, as it's so often contrived and feels insincere in a way. But with Kara, it felt a lot more realistic imo

---

Also I come for this show a lot, but damn I love everything about Alex's subplot
ZeroX03
Member
(10-16-2017, 08:54 AM)
ZeroX03's Avatar
All new episode of SUPERGIRL THE VIRGIN tonight!

#3.02 "Triggers"
Episode Promo

YAEL GROBGLAS (“JANE THE VIRGIN”) GUEST STARS — Psi (guest star Yael Grobglas), a thief with psychic powers, attacks National City. Able to immobilize people by tapping into their worst fears, Psi proves a formidable opponent for Supergirl, who fears she can't carry a show without Mon-El. Meanwhile, James (Mehcad Brooks) and Lena (Katie McGrath) are at an impasse, and Samantha starts her new job at L-Corp. David McWhirter directed the episode written by Gabriel Llanas & Anna Musky-Goldwyn (#302).

The Hobo
Member
(10-16-2017, 09:11 AM)
The Hobo's Avatar
It's weird that we didn't get any reaction from Cat about her company being bought out.
OdysseusVA
Banned
(10-16-2017, 08:37 PM)

Originally Posted by ZeroX03

All new episode of SUPERGIRL THE VIRGIN tonight!

#3.02 "Triggers"
Episode Promo

Hmmm
With or without?
Effect
Member
(10-16-2017, 08:46 PM)
Effect's Avatar

Originally Posted by Freddy=Legend

Katie McGrath's accent has been slipping out a little this episode. Maybe my ears just playing tricks on me.

They should have just let her keep it given that her character didn't have the same mother as Lex and did spend several years with her birth mother before she went to level with Luthors. The can easily say she was outside the US for a number of years and she picked up the accent again. If a person can't keep the accent down then don't bother trying to hide. It's bad when they slip up.
BLOODED_hands
Member
(10-16-2017, 08:50 PM)
BLOODED_hands's Avatar

Originally Posted by ZeroX03

All new episode of SUPERGIRL THE VIRGIN tonight!

#3.02 "Triggers"
Episode Promo

*Picture* something something Brazzers logo something something

Anyways, time for Jobbergirl to job tonight.
caliph95
Member
(10-16-2017, 08:51 PM)
caliph95's Avatar

Originally Posted by BLOODED_hands

*Picture* something something Brazzers logo something something

Anyways, time for Jobbergirl to job tonight.

*insert lip bite gif*
DeathyBoy
Banned
(10-16-2017, 10:32 PM)
That woman with the kid is gonna be Night Girl from the Legion. Calling it now.

Thread Tools